Indonesia’s hostile treatment of journalists, highlighted by last month’s arrests of two French reporters in West Papua, desperately, needs to stop!
Despite assurances made to the contrary,
there is nothing under the pacific sun that is new
regarding Indonesia’s deadly and demoralizing
tactics used to terrorize anyone who would dare
exercise any small amount of press freedom.
A Brief History of Media Disintegration
- May 2010: French journalist, Baudouin Koenig, was arrested for photographing Papuan-independence demonstrations in the city of Jayapura.
- Sept 2010: Tabloid Jubi reporter, Ardiansyah Matrais was brutally murdered and his body dumped in a river for reporting on “environmental impacts and local politics.”
- Oct 2011: The Pacific Media Center issued a disturbing special report on the state of Pacific media freedom for 2011. The report, published in the Pacific Journalism Review (Volume 17, Issue 2), stated: “By far the most serious case of media freedom violations in the Pacific is in Indonesian-ruled West Papua… At least two journalists have been killed, five abducted and 18 assaulted in the past year.”
- April 2012: Journalists Leiron Kogoya and Marlon Mramra were killed for covering police and military abuses, together with the story of a police officer who had raped someone in a police station. Kogoya, who was covering local elections in Puncak Jaya for the Papua Post, was fatally shot through the neck by police in an incident where 4 others sustained injuries, including a child and his mother.
July 2013: The Indonesian Minister of Foreign
Affairs, Marty Natalegawa, dishonestly defended the foreign media ban by warning of unnamed “elements in Papua who are keen to gain international attention by doing harm to international personalities including journalists.”
Last Month’s Ordeal (Ongoing)
- August 6th 2014: French Journalists Valentine Bourrat and Thomas Dandois were arrested in West Papua on immigration charges.
They were charged with misuse of a visitor permit and taken into custody in Jayapura. The Indonesian government has also alleged they were meeting with and providing ammunition to separatists, and are considering adding the charge of “subversion” which comes with a possible 20 year prison term.
A local indigenous leader whom the journalists had interviewed, Areki Wanimbo, was arrested along with them, and initially not given access to a lawyer or any clear indication of what he was charged with. Authorities have since charged him with “treason”, and he too faces a 20 year jail sentence.
The journalists, who were filming a documentary about human rights abuses, have apologized for breaking Indonesian immigration laws, and their production company have guaranteed they will not produce any material that would discredit Indonesia. Their trial is set to begin in roughly 2 weeks.
Normally journalists caught working in West Papua on tourist visas are deported.
According to Victor Mambor, chairperson of the West Papua branch of the Alliance of Independent Journalists, this harsh treatment is intended to send a message to international journalists that West Papua is still very much off limits. He also explained that permits for journalists are not easy to obtain in West Papua and involve being constantly accompanied by government agents. Mambor expects the journalists to be found guilty but serve less than the five year sentence sought for immigration violations.
Bourrat and Dandois were arrested in Wamena, West Papua, a remote region which has often been the scene of atrocities committed against indigenous Papuans by Indonesian security forces.
Authorities have also alleged that the French journalists were receiving advice and assistance from “NC” in Australia, identified as Nick Chesterfield of West Papua Media, and threatened him with arrest. Chesterfield stated that “assisting journalists is a basic element of freedom of the press” and is not a crime under international law. The Southeast Asian Press Alliance have called the arrest and detention of these journalists illegal, and West Papuan activists including KNPB Chairman, Victor Yeimo, have called for their immediate release.
While Indonesia’s treatment of international journalists in West Papua is scandalous, it’s also important to remember that this is just one minor incident among thousands of far worse abuses carried out against indigenous Papuans under the Indonesian occupation. In the midst of this case, KNPB leader Martinus Yohame disappeared mysteriously one day after criticizing Indonesian president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono in a press conference. He was found dead, tied up in sack off the shore of Nana Island on August 26th. He had been beaten and shot in the chest. The KNPB has accused the Indonesian military of being behind the killing. In recent weeks, prominent West Papuan human rights lawyer, Gustaf Kawer, has also faced intimidation from Indonesian authorities and has been threatened with arrest.
These are not the actions of a democratic nation.
The international community must immediately put pressure on new Indonesian president Joko Widodo to finally begin an honest discussion with West Papuan indigenous leaders about self-determination and the protection of basic human rights.
To learn more about how to help Mr. Dandois, Ms. Bourrat, and Mr. Wanimbo, as well as all journalists and defenders of human rights in West Papua, see this appeal from TAPOL.